Why Most Toddler Parenting Advice Isn’t Working (And How We're Doing It Differently)

Jeanine Cambra • July 14, 2025

“Toddler Tantrums and Big Feelings: A Montessori Guide for Calm, Connection, and Confidence

The sudden scream in the grocery aisle, the stomped feet, the tears spilling over . . . toddler tantrums can feel like an emotional storm hitting out of nowhere.  Many parents find themselves searching for answers, desperate for advice that actually works in those moments.


But here’s the thing: most of the parenting advice out there falls short because it focuses on quick fixes or control, rather than understanding the
why behind these big feelings.


At Sandwich Montessori School, we believe parenting toddlers is less about “stopping tantrums” and more about building connection, independence, and respect rooted in Montessori principles that honor your child’s natural growth.


In this post, we’ll explore why so much advice misses the mark and how a Montessori-inspired approach can bring calm and confidence to your family.


1. The Challenge With Typical Toddler Advice

Have you ever tried a parenting “hack” that promised quick results but left you feeling more frustrated?  You’re not alone.


Many common tips focus on
quick fixes . . . stop the tantrum now, get your toddler to obey, enforce rules firmly.  This advice doesn’t take into account toddlers are learning to handle huge feelings with very few words and even fewer tools to express themselves.


So when advice doesn’t match their stage of growth, it often feels like a mismatch, like you’re speaking a different language from your toddler’s heart.


Here’s the reality:


  • Discipline-only approaches can feel harsh or disconnected from your child’s needs
  • One-size-fits-all advice ignores your toddler’s unique personality and rhythm
  • Overwhelming or conflicting tips leave you second-guessing yourself


Have you felt like this?  Like the advice out there just isn’t quite for your family?


2. What Toddlers Really Need From Parents

Toddlers don’t want to be “controlled”, they want to be understood.


What they really need is:


  • Security:  routines that help them feel safe and steady
  • Independence:  chances to make choices and feel capable
  • Understanding:  adults who recognize their feelings as real and important
  • Calm guidance:  gentle limits that teach without shaming

Montessori parenting focusses exactly on these needs, offering a respectful, child-focused way to build connection and confidence.



Try this Mini-Challenge:
Notice how your toddler responds when you offer a simple choice, like “Would you like the blue cup or the red cup?”  That small moment can feel like a big win for their independence.


3. How Montessori Principles Support You and Your Toddler

Montessori isn’t just for schools, it’s a way to live and parent that honors your child’s whole development.

Here’s what it looks like at home:


  • Prepared environment:  A space set up so your toddler can explore safely and freely
  • Positive discipline:  Teaching with calm and clarity, not punishment
  • Behavior as communication:  Seeing tantrums and “misbehavior” as messages, not defiance
  • Consistent routines:  Building daily rhythms that reduce stress and foster trust

I’ve seen firsthand how a small change, like creating a low shelf with accessible toys, can boost a toddler’s confidence and reduce frustration.


4. What You Can Expect From Our Parenting Course

Our upcoming digital caregiver course is built to help busy parents like you bring Montessori principles into everyday life, without overwhelm.


You’ll find:

  • Simple strategies for calm mornings, smooth transitions, and growing independence
  • Ways to handle tantrums and power struggles with kindness and effectiveness
  • Easy home setup ideas to support your toddler’s growth
  • Support designed for real families juggling all the things


Parenting toddlers is one of life’s greatest joys . . . and, let’s be honest, one of its biggest challenges.


You don’t have to go it alone, or try to fit yourself into advice that doesn’t quite match your family’s unique rhythm.


I’m excited to share this journey with you and support your toddler’s growth with respect and care.


As we put the finishing touches on our full digital course, we invite you to join our free 7-day email course, where every day you’ll get a simple, Montessori-inspired idea to try with your toddler.


Yes, I want the strategies from the FREE 7-day course . . . click here: 
Seven Days to a Calm & Connected Home


Materials Spotlight: The Geometry Cabinet
February 26, 2024
Geometry is a subject that is taught through all education levels. Learn more about the simple Geometry Cabinet material in Montessori and all of its uses.
We Can Serve as Guides
February 19, 2024
Typically, we think of guides as the teachers in the Montessori classroom, however, we as adults can be guides too. Learn more about how to make the shift.
Our Montessori Bookshelf: Cultivating Emotional Intelligence this Valentine’s Day
February 12, 2024
Emotional intelligence is hard for a parent to teach to children. By using books they can act as a mirror for children and make these emotions more relatable.
The Capstone Years
February 5, 2024
Age 6 and age 12 in Montessori are referred to as the capstone years. During these years children really dive into big work and develop their self-confidence.
Trust the Process: Montessori as an Intentional Approach
January 29, 2024
The Montessori approach can be intimidating at times. There are many misconceptions about Montessori but the methodology is backed by results.
In Support of Spoken Language
January 22, 2024
Spoken language is very appealing to our primary-aged children. In our classrooms, you will see and hear lots of games happening around language development.
Our Montessori Bookshelf: In Honor of MLK Day
January 15, 2024
In honor of Martin Luther King Jr. Day we have recommended some books about him and his movement.
Social Benefits: The Elementary Years
January 8, 2024
Social and emotional learning is a hot topic in today's education world. Montessori elementary environments have this built into their curriculum.
Why Intrinsic Motivation Matters
January 1, 2024
What’s the difference between taking a walk to keep up with a workplace exercise challenge and taking a walk because you want to? Intrinsic motivation.
Creating Family Rituals
December 25, 2023
The holidays is a wonderful time to start rituals as a family. If you have a few that you practice, this read will give you some more to add to your list.
Show More